Follow the Feud

Ryan / April 14th, 2008

AVGN vs. Nostalgia Critic

4/18/08 – Nostalgia Critic calls out AVGN

4/19/08 – AVGN responds on forum. Nostalgia Critic analyzes hidden meaning.

4/27/08 – Nostalgia Critic is furious over AVGN’s “The Wizard” review.

5/4/08 – Nostalgia Critic reviews “The Wizard” and makes a radical discovery at the end.

6/12/08 – AVGN makes his long awaited video response to the Nostalgia Critic.

6/15/08 – Nostalgia Critic challenges AVGN to review a bad movie.

6/29/08 – LIVE appearance. Nostalgia Critic meets AVGN at Digital Press video game store with Captain S. The three of them fight to a stalemate. Finally, AVGN accepts the challenge to review a bad movie, and in return, challenges Nostalgia Critic to review a bad game.

7/28/08 – AVGN reviews the movie Ricky 1, and is furious at Nostalgia Critic for making him watch it.

8/3/08 – The Nostalgia Critic reviews the SNES game Bebe’s Kids, mimicking the Nerd and growing furious as well.

9/24/08 – Both declare war!

10/10/08 – THE FINAL BATTLE!

10/25/08 – Retrospective

11/16/08 – Outtakes

5/10/09 – Team brawl

6/10/09 – TMNT: Coming Out of Their Shells


  • April 8, 2010 at 7:44 pm

    I admit the whole feud is pretty silly, but it does help introduce me to Doug Walker’s work including the NC and my personal favorite, the Bum!

    Though I prefer you James, I really like both of you guys along with Spoony and Linkara because you guys keep me entertained every day!

  • NaokiB2U

    June 9, 2010 at 3:46 am

    I always watch these every few months to make me laugh. Oddly enough i only JUST NOW found the video where you and the critic collaborated on the shitty turtles band movie haha. You should put it on the timeline!

  • July 29, 2010 at 6:55 pm

    Wow, lol that took a long time to watch all of it xD

  • September 3, 2010 at 5:16 pm

    Please add this link to the list

    “Specials: TGWTG 1 Year Anniversary Brawl (Edit 2)”

    An awesome brawl…..really funny

  • Nerdy Nerd

    January 29, 2011 at 9:07 am


  • LicaWolf

    January 18, 2013 at 9:45 pm

    Oh, I loved the feud so much and it still helds a special place in my heart.

    I probably wouldn’t have gone to MAGfest this year if it wasn’t because I discovered TGWTG through the feud in the first place. It was an expensive flight (my first time travelling abroad), but I tried hard to get the money because there were many reviewers I wanted to meet (including James). I made so many cool friends there, both AVGN and TGWTG fans and it was an overall amazing experience. I’m pretty sure none of that would have happened without the feud, and for that I’m eternally grateful.

    Maybe this should be updated with the ConBravo panel and The Nerd helping the Critic in the Fourth Anniversary movie?

    Also, I hope Doug brings back the Critic just to review the AVGN movie. Not because I think it will be bad –I’m loving the trailer and I can’t wait to watch it– but because it has the potential to be pretty funny 😛 (Critic’s final revenge xD)

Leave a Reply

James’ favorites